The Cheapest Online Brokers for Retail Traders

by David John Hall on September 28, 2011 · 2 comments

in Articles, Blog, Trading Education

  • Share

When it comes to trading small accounts, there’s one cost you need to take into account more than any other: commissions.

With some online brokers charging as much as $14.99 per buy and $14.99 per sell, a $30.00 round turn can really affect profits on smaller accounts.

For this reason I suggest you shop around for all of your services.  And at the very top of that shopping list should be the all important online trading brokers.

Currently, I’m with Zecco.com and I would give them an A for effort (even though they’ve been steadily raising their commissions from the low, low cost of $0.00 which is where they started out).

I’ve never had a problem with customer service when I call and their execution speed (while not up to direct access levels) has been pretty awesome.

The other 3 discount brokerages I know of are:

TradeKing
SogoTrades
Scottrade

To be fair, I only have experience with Scottrade.

Though their commissions come in a little high at $7.95 per trade they do offer real time, streaming quotes for free — where as Zecco.com charges extra for a streaming platform.

Scottrade also lets you open an account with $500.00 and has actual brick and mortar offices your you can walk into in the real world. However, you still need $2,000.00 to get a margin account because if you don’t have one you’ll have to let funds settle for 3 days otherwise before making a new trade.

This used to bother me a lot — but that’s when my trade lengths were getting shorter and shorter.

Now I’m fine with end of day charts and delayed data because that’s how I trade. The only thing I am looking at for when it comes to small or micro accounts is the best free/cheap alternative to get something done that I need to get done in the market.

Given that I will very soon begin a trading challenge each year whereby I take a small $2,000.00 account and try and trade it up to something meaningful using whatever methods I can dream up, those lower commissions will really come in handy.

To give you an example, let’s look at the difference in price between Zecco and Scottrade over 1 year trading a conservative 2 times a month.

Scottrade Trade Commissions
Trades = 24 (2 trades per month x 12 months)
Commissions = $381.60 ($7.95 each buy and $7.95 for each sell = 48 x $7.95)

That’s 19% I need to make on my money just to cover the cost of commissions on my trades.

Now, let’s look at Zecco.com or Tradeking.com.

Zecco.com or Tradeking.com Trade Commissions
Trades = 24 (2 trades per month x 12 months)
Commissions = $237.60 ($4.95 each buy and $4.95 for each sell = 48 x $7.95)

At $237.60, (11.88% of total equity) these commissions are over $100.00 less than Scottrades. Not to mention how much they’re below the cost of brokerages that charge $14.95 per trade!

Let’s Recap…

When it comes to small accounts you want commissions to be as low as possible because the higher they go the more they eat into your profits and exacerbate your losses.

You want to trade as infrequently as possible because active trading means more commissions.

And if you can get away with and/or find free alternatives (and you can because you are here at RetailTrader!) to what some online brokers might make you pay for — then go for it!

Why?

Because every dollar in your account is another dollar that’s earning interest — that’s why!

This post was written by...

– who has written 127 posts

David has been trading non-stop for 6 years. He lives in Redondo Beach, California (an awesome place to live) and is super stoked to be able to blog about his passion here.

Contact David John Hall

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Sandra November 29, 2011 at 6:12 AM

This information is off the hiozol!

Reply

David John Hall March 20, 2012 at 7:58 AM

Thanks Sandra — you’re off the hizol, too!

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: